OpinionIran in the World PressMaliki is the cause of violence in Iraq not...

Maliki is the cause of violence in Iraq not the solution

-

Huffington Post: The U.S. is on track to ignore Nuri Al Maliki’s unaccountability and to strengthen his government, playing directly into the hands of the Iranian regime. A new dictator is today prowling the streets of Baghdad and it appears he still has the backing of President Obama.
The Huffington Post

By Lord Maginnis – Member of the British Parliamentary Committee for Iran Freedom

On Friday, February 27, 2009 President Barack Obama stood before a crowd of U.S. Marines and spoke of responsibly ending the war in Iraq after years of suffering and bloodshed for Americans and Iraqis alike. In his address, President Obama stated:

“…we will work to promote an Iraqi government that is just, representative, and accountable, and that provides neither support nor safe-haven to terrorists.”

That promise has been broken by President Obama. The U.S. is on track to ignore Nuri Al Maliki’s unaccountability and to strengthen his government, playing directly into the hands of the Iranian regime. A new dictator is today prowling the streets of Baghdad and it appears he still has the backing of President Obama.

One such example of Nuri Al-Maliki’s dictatorial leadership is the massacre of Iranian dissidents at Camp Ashraf in Iraq. During the early morning hours of September 1st, Iraqi forces massacred 52 unarmed Iranian dissidents and took a further seven hostage. Those seven, six of whom are women and all of whom were unarmed civilians, remain hostage. Despite Iraq’s denial that they are in possession of the hostages, evidence to the contrary has been overwhelming.

During a September correspondence with Alejo Vidal-Quadras, Vice-President of the European Parliament, the EU High Representative, Baroness Ashton had already expressed doubt regarding Iraq’s denial stating:

“…we have reason to believe that up to seven camp residents are being held in captivity near Baghdad.”

Since that time, the voices of a number of international organizations and government figures, including those in the United States, joined in agreement with the E.U.’s conclusion. Further, recent evidence has shown that the hostages are being held in a prison run by Prime Minister Maliki’s son.

If the hostages are deported to Iran by the Iraqi government we know they will be brutally tortured and face certain death. They would meet this fate despite the fact that they are defined as Protected Persons under the Fourth Geneva Convention and have been given explicit promises of protection by the U.S. government. The only way this gruesome outcome can be prevented is a united stand by those in the West led by the United States.

Europe has affirmed the importance of saving the lives of these seven innocent Iranians, adopting a resolution on October 10th that cut across routinely divided party lines. The resolution condemned the senseless attack on Camp Ashraf and called for the immediate release of those being held. Struan Stevenson, who chairs the European Parliament’s Delegation for Relations with Iraq called the resolution:

“… a warning to the government of Iraq that if the 7 hostages are not released, the EU will no longer have business as usual with Maliki’s government and we will use all measures to restrict Europe’s trade links with Baghdad.”

Such sentiment adds to the growing chorus of condemnation, which includes U.N. bodies, human rights organizations such as Amnesty International and a number of U.S. Senators.

Just as in the European Parliament, an earlier U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing revealed a sentiment of rare bi-partisan agreement. Republican Senator John McCain and Democratic Senator Bob Menendez both condemned the actions of the Iraqi government and highlighted the importance of helping the 7 kidnapped Iranians.

Senator Menendez, chairman of the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee, showed just how harmful further bloodshed would be, stating:

“…it is unacceptable to lose one more life when American commanders gave these individuals a written guarantee toward their safety – it would send a message to others in the world that they should not trust us when we say that we are going to do something and we fail to do it.”

With strong international and domestic support, which has shown the rare trait of cutting across party lines, President Obama and the United States must not adopt a platform of silence. To do so, would be to set back the credibility of the U.S, Europe and the international community and constitute complicity in the kidnapping and murder of innocent civilians. The first step in breaking this unacceptable silence is a simple one; to publicly demand that the Iraqi PM, Nuri al-Maliki, releases the seven Iranian dissidents his Special Forces are holding as hostages in Baghdad.

As long as the hostages are unjustly held, and suffering through abhorrent conditions, the U.S. should not adopt silence in dealing with the captors. Instead they must demand that Maliki releases the hostages now or future bilateral relations could be harmed.

Latest news

Inflation in Iran and the Limits of What an Agreement with the United States Can Achieve

A sick political system inevitably produces a sick economy. In an absolute dictatorship where political and social freedoms are...

Day 2 of Free Iran 2026: International Figures Rally Behind NCRI Alternative

PARIS — The second day of the Free Iran 2026 World Summit brought together a broad range of former...

Free Iran 2026 Summit in Paris Draws International Support for Democratic Change in Iran

PARIS, June 20, 2026 — Political leaders, former government officials, parliamentarians, and human rights advocates from Europe and North...

Iran’s Water Crisis: Women on the Front Lines of a Silent Disaster

Iran’s water crisis is no longer merely an environmental or economic challenge; it has become one of the country’s...

Child Laborers: The Silent Victims of Poverty and Inflation in Iran

On June 15, the state-run Shargh newspaper published a report on child labor titled "Childhood on a Work Shift,"...

Iran’s Regime Executes Political Prisoners Javad Zamani and Abolfazl Saedi

Iran's regime hanged two young men, Javad Zamani and Abolfazl Saedi, in the early hours of Tuesday, June 16,...

Must read

Iran backs OPEC moves for production cut

AFP: Iran, OPEC's second largest producer, on Sunday threw...

Disputes emerge on Iran and roadside bombs

New York Times: Bush administration officials, intelligence analysts and...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you