OpinionIran in the World PressFor Iran ‘breakthrough,’ coalition cannot break down

For Iran ‘breakthrough,’ coalition cannot break down

-

Bloomberg: The word “breakthrough” has been uttered hopefully in anticipation of the meeting May 23 in Baghdad of officials from six world powers and Iran to resolve the standoff over Iran’s nuclear program.

Bloomberg

By Vali Nasr

The word “breakthrough” has been uttered hopefully in anticipation of the meeting May 23 in Baghdad of officials from six world powers and Iran to resolve the standoff over Iran’s nuclear program. A positive meeting last month in Istanbul kindled a sense of momentum.

The U.S., which has kept the talks on track as Iran has tried to wiggle out of them, wants Iran to freeze its program and agree to future negotiations on capping uranium enrichment and opening nuclear sites to full international inspection. But success will continue to rely on the unified U.S., European, Russian and Chinese decision to impose punishing economic sanctions on Iran, and that cohesion is now under threat.
About Vali Nasr

It’s shaky not just because Russia and China are, as usual, difficult to keep in the corral. The new and greater challenge is the risk that the just-elected French president will break ranks and that economic woes will lead to a further dissolution of European resolve to confront Iran’s nuclear program.

Before Nicolas Sarkozy became president in 2007, France, like the rest of Europe, took a softer approach to Iran than the U.S. But Sarkozy was hawkish on Iran, and eager to move France closer to the U.S. He argued for robust international sanctions to compel Iran to give up its presumed nuclear weapons program. His approach influenced the U.K., and eventually hardened the position of the rest of Europe. Under Sarkozy, France led Europe in insisting on a tightening of financial pressure and a European embargo on Iranian oil, set to begin July 1.

France’s new Socialist president, Francois Hollande, is distancing himself from Sarkozy’s legacy, including on the Iran policy. Shortly after Hollande’s victory, former Socialist Prime Minister Michel Rocard visited Iran on a private but symbolic trip. Although Hollande has publicly pronounced his support for the U.S. position, it was clear from the comments of Iranian officials who met with Rocard that they are confident France will no longer serve as the hard line at the negotiating table.

Continuing economic troubles pose another challenge to European unity on Iran. The boycott of Iranian oil may lead to higher energy prices in Europe, which could prove unpopular, especially on top of austerity measures that are already emboldening the populist left across the region. Iran might pursue the strategy it has adopted with China and offer struggling European economies oil at discount prices. Confronting Iran may no longer be a European priority in the face of the region’s grave financial problems.

If Europe slides, it would be difficult for the U.S. to keep China and Russia in the fold, especially with both sets of relations recently tested. A cloud hangs over U.S.-China ties after the diplomatic tussle over dissident Chen Guangcheng, who sought refuge in the U.S. Embassy in Beijing. As Iran’s largest trading partner, China has significant control over whether the sanctions regime works. Only recently has China begun to enforce sanctions, cutting its Iranian oil imports by 11 percent. It can do much more to curtail Iranian financial transactions and trade.

Russia has always balanced its strategic relationship with Iran with keeping the U.S. content. The “reset” of U.S.-Russia relations during the Obama administration’s first year tilted that balance in Washington’s favor. But there is growing suspicion of U.S. intentions in Russia and a willingness to score political points by feeding anti-Americanism. Thus the Kremlin is in no mood to do the U.S. any favors on Iran and instead prefers obduracy.

To Iran, this is all welcome news: The international alliance against its nuclear program is losing focus and may unravel. Almost certainly, there will be no further sanctions, and those on the books will be implemented inconsistently. Such a reading will probably lead Iran to take a confident, uncompromising position in the nuclear negotiations.

The challenge, then, is to keep intact the international alliance that was created to prevent just that. The U.S. should work harder at mending fences with Russia and China to keep them onboard. And European officials should exercise leadership in keeping this crucial security matter on their agenda. Otherwise, Iran will have no reason to resolve the nuclear issue. Far from a breakthrough, what we can expect from the nuclear talks in that case is a long, slow and frustrating process.

(Vali Nasr is a Bloomberg View contributor, a professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University and a senior fellow in foreign policy at the Brookings Institution. The opinions expressed are his own.)

Latest news

Iran’s Regime Claims To Fill Global Energy Gap Despite Crippled Petroleum Sector

In recent weeks, the Iranian regime’s officials have been constantly exaggerating their huge capacity in oil and gas reserves...

What Is Happening in Iran?

Following the brutal killing of Masha Amini, the Iranian people have once again united to fight and defeat the...

Iran Regime’s Ministry of Culture’s Decision To Eliminate Children’s Intellectual Centers

With the so-called ‘Cultural Revolution’ which took place between 1980 and 1983, the Iranian regime tried to purge the...

Water Shortage Crisis and the Destruction of Iran’s Water Resources

Iran is currently suffering from a number of dangerous natural disasters. One of the most worrying is the drying...

Economic Freedom Under the Rule of the Mullahs in Iran

The Fraser institute published its annual report of the index of economic freedom on September 8, which measured the...

Iran’s Regime Continues Its Internet Restriction Project

This is part of the outlook of a document by the Iranian regime’s Supreme Council of Cyberspace, which has...

Must read

Iran says $200/barrel oil possible: report

Reuters: Iran's Oil Minister Gholamhossein Nozari said it would...

Ahmadinejad: ‘American empire’ nearing its end

CNN: In a blistering speech before the United Nations...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you